Field Guides

Fish Hydrolysate vs Fish Emulsion: Which Is Better for Field Crops?

Neither is "better" on every acre. Here is how the two are made, what each keeps, and how they handle in a sprayer or in-furrow kit.

Two jars of liquid fish fertilizer, one darker and one lighter, on a truck tailgate by a soybean field

Fish emulsion and fish hydrolysate are both liquid fish fertilizers, but they are made differently, so they leave different things in the jug. For field crops, the better choice is the one whose label, analysis and handling fit your sprayer and your program, and you find that out by reading the label and running a strip trial.

Diagram: Fish emulsion vs fish hydrolysate: Two routes from fish to a liquid fertilizer
Fish emulsion vs fish hydrolysate

How is fish emulsion made?

Illinois Extension describes fish emulsion as "the leftover liquid from the fish meal and fish oil industry." The maker strains out solid pieces and adjusts the pH so the product does not spoil. The same page says a typical fish emulsion may be about 2-4-1 and that nutrient ratios may vary, so use the label on the jug in front of you.

Because emulsion starts as a by-product of meal and oil production, ask the maker what the raw material was.

How is fish hydrolysate made?

The USDA National Organic Program technical report on fish-based fertilizers (July 2019) describes it this way: fish or fish waste is minced, put in a tank, sometimes with salt, and broken down. The breakdown is done by enzymes already in the fish, or by added proteolytic enzymes. Once the proteins are broken down enough, the process is stopped by heating or by pH adjustment.

The same report lists fish emulsions, fish hydrolysate, fish solubles, fish silage and liquid fish as other names for fish-based fertilizers, so you will see the words mixed on labels and websites.

Where does cold-fermented whole salmon fit?

TNT HEF is made from naturally fermented whole saltwater salmon, using a cold process. It is a fermented product, not an emulsion. TNT describes Super Salmon+ as a fortified salmon hydrolysate with kelp and chitin, made with a portion of that same fermented salmon. If a seller uses the word "hydrolysate" for everything, ask what the fish was, whether it was whole, and how the process was stopped.

What does each process leave in the jug?

In our Talk Time session What’s Up With Fish? we walked through the three liquid routes this way:

  • Hydrolysate: digested just enough to liquefy the flesh. It keeps the fish’s free oils, some nutrients are available right away, and the rest is released as soil microbes digest it further, so it acts as a natural slow-release feed.
  • Emulsion: a hydrolysate-like liquid with the oils pulled out, usually by cooking. It behaves much like a hydrolysate.
  • Fermented: the breakdown is carried all the way through by natural fermentation. That is the route TNT HEF takes with whole saltwater salmon, and it is why HEF 2-0-0 tests at over 70% volatile fatty acids on a dry-matter basis (Dairy One report 24338880). Volatile fatty acids and amino acids are ready food for soil fungi and bacteria.
Checklist of four things to check before buying any liquid fish product: raw material, analysis, OMRI listing and handling
Four checks for any liquid fish product, then a strip trial on your own ground.

Fish emulsion vs hydrolysate: side by side

QuestionFish emulsionFish hydrolysateFermented whole salmon (TNT HEF)
Starting materialLiquid left from fish meal and oil production (Illinois Extension)Whole fish or fish waste, minced (USDA NOP report, 2019)Whole saltwater salmon
How it breaks downStrained from meal and oil production; ask the makerEnzymes, from the fish or addedNatural fermentation, cold process
How it is stabilizedpH adjusted so it does not spoilHeat or pH adjustment stops the enzymesSee the label and SDS
Typical analysis2-4-1 given as a typical example; variesVaries by brandHEF 2-0-0 and 2-3-0; Super Salmon+ 2-2-0
Smell"Smells, well like blended up fish" (Illinois Extension)VariesMild marine smell from the jug; fades within hours on soil
Check before buyingGuaranteed analysis, OMRI listingGuaranteed analysis, OMRI listingGuaranteed analysis, OMRI listing

Which one handles better in a sprayer?

Handling is where most field-crop jobs are won or lost. Whatever you buy, ask these four questions.

  1. Filter size. A 180 mesh screen is too fine for TNT fish products; fit 50 mesh or coarser. Super Salmon+ arrives pre-screened at 120 mesh, which does not replace the strainer your equipment calls for.
  2. Agitation. Keep the tank agitating, with a return line, so biological products do not settle.
  3. Jar test. Test with your starter, herbicide or liquid fertilizer before you fill the tank. Watch for curdling, especially with humates.
  4. Same water as the field. Mix with the water you will actually spray.

Super Salmon+ is biologically active once diluted, so TNT's guidance is to use it within 4 hours for peak performance.

Why do fish fertilizers plug sprayers, and how do I stop it?

Almost always it is the screens, not the product. Growers new to fish products often still have 180 mesh screens in from their chemical program, and those catch the fine solids that a biological liquid carries. The fixes from the same session are simple:

  • Fit 50 mesh or coarser at the main tank filter.
  • Check the small inline filters right before each nozzle. They are the ones people forget; take them out or swap them for coarse ones.
  • Use a coarser droplet. Twinjet flat fan tips with strainers sized to the tip, and at least 10 gallons of water per acre for foliar passes, rather than a very fine mist at low volume.
  • Jar test with your own water. Very hard water can turn a mix cloudy; the jar shows you before the tank does.

Why does the label word matter less than the analysis?

"Emulsion," "hydrolysate," "hydrolyzed" and "fermented" are marketing words as much as process words. The USDA report lists hydrolysate, silage and emulsion as names for one broad group, and Illinois Extension notes that emulsion nutrient ratios may vary. Two jugs with the same word on the front can carry different nitrogen, different phosphate and a different pH. That is why the guaranteed analysis and the product's pH and specific gravity belong in your comparison, along with the price per unit of what you actually want from the jug.

Also check the pH. Low-pH products can behave differently in a tank mix than neutral ones, and that is exactly what a jar test is for. Mix a small batch in the same water, in the same order you will use in the tank, let it sit, and look for curdling, layers or clumps before you commit a full load.

What about in-furrow?

The TNT HEF in-furrow rate is 2-4 qt/acre, diluted at least 1:10 at planting. A phosphorus-bearing option such as TNT HEF 2-3-0 (2-3-0, OMRI Listed for US organic) fits a cool-soil starter, and TNT HEF 2-0-0 fits programs where phosphorus is not limiting. Whichever liquid you pick, calibrate the kit, jar test it with the starter and check for plugging before you plant a full field.

Can fish replace my nitrogen?

No. The guaranteed analysis is low: HEF 2-0-0 carries 2% total nitrogen. Treat any liquid fish product as a biological and nutrition add-on, not a bulk nitrogen source. In the 2025 TNT corn trial, tissue tests were used to decide whether to skip a side-dress. That was one farm and one season, results vary, and you can read both trials in full on the reports page.

What if I farm organic?

Do not choose by the words "emulsion" or "hydrolysate." Choose by the OMRI listing for your standard. Among TNT products, only HEF 2-3-0 (tna-16447) and TNT Super Salmon+ (tna-17020) are OMRI Listed for US organic (NOP), and listings expire 1 March 2027. HEF 2-0-0 is OMRI Listed for Canada (COR) only. See which TNT products are OMRI listed, and search the product yourself at omri.org.

How do I pick one for my farm?

  • Read the guaranteed analysis and compare per gallon, not per brand name.
  • Ask what fish it is made from, and whether the whole fish is used.
  • Check the OMRI listing, the standard (NOP or COR) and the expiry date.
  • Confirm the filter mesh and the dilution before you load the tank.
  • Run two products side by side on matched strips, on your ground, and compare at harvest.

If you are comparing brands, the fish fertilizer brand comparison lists the facts that are on each label. TNT also offers a free sample for a strip trial at /free-sample.

Sources

  • Christopher Enroth, University of Illinois Extension, "Scale up your garden's health with fish emulsion fertilizer," April 25, 2022.
  • USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, National Organic Program, Technical Evaluation Report on fish-based fertilizers, July 26, 2019.
  • TNT product labels, SDS and Midwest Laboratories reports.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between fish hydrolysate and fish emulsion?
Fish emulsion is the leftover liquid from the fish meal and fish oil industry, strained and pH-adjusted so it does not spoil (Illinois Extension). Fish hydrolysate is made from minced fish or fish waste broken down by the fish's own enzymes or added ones, then the process is stopped by heating or pH adjustment (USDA National Organic Program technical report, 2019).
Is fish hydrolysate the same as fish silage?
The USDA National Organic Program technical report on fish-based fertilizers (2019) lists fish silage, fish hydrolysate, fish emulsions and liquid fish among the other names for fish-based fertilizers. It does not draw a line between silage and hydrolysate, so ask the maker how the product was made.
Is TNT HEF a hydrolysate or an emulsion?
TNT HEF 2-0-0 and HEF 2-3-0 are made from naturally fermented whole saltwater salmon with a cold process. TNT Super Salmon+ is a fortified salmon hydrolysate with kelp and chitin. Neither is an emulsion.
Which one is OMRI Listed?
It depends on the product, not the category. Among TNT products, only HEF 2-3-0 and Super Salmon+ are OMRI Listed for US organic (NOP), and listings expire 1 March 2027. HEF 2-0-0 is OMRI Listed for Canada (COR) only. Check any product on the OMRI site before you buy.
What sprayer filter should I use with fish products?
For TNT fish products, use a 50 mesh or coarser filter, not 180 mesh. Super Salmon+ is filtered to 120 mesh, but you should still filter to your equipment specs. Keep the tank agitating and run a jar test first.
Can I put fish fertilizer in the in-furrow kit?
Yes. HEF goes in the furrow at 2-4 qt/acre, with at least ten parts water to one part product. Do a jar test with your starter first, and keep it agitated.
Will either one replace my nitrogen?
No. These are low-analysis products. HEF 2-0-0 guarantees 2% total nitrogen. Use them as a biological and nutrition add-on, and check your own nitrogen plan with tissue tests and a strip trial.

Written by

TNT Farming Solutions

Fermented fish fertilizer maker, Versailles, Indiana, since 2017

TNT makes and sells its own fermented salmon fertilizers and biostimulants to row-crop, hay and specialty growers in all 50 states, runs replicated on-farm trials with RhizeBio, and publishes its lab analyses and OMRI certificates.

Product facts checked against the current labels, Midwest Laboratories analyses and OMRI listings. Last reviewed 2026-11-22.

YouTubeFacebookInstagramThreads Contact

Want to try it on your own ground?

Get a free sample or request a custom quote for your operation.

Best Selling Products

Discover why farmers choose TNT HEF for their soil health programs.