Neptune's Harvest vs TNT HEF 2-3-0
Two OMRI Listed liquid fish fertilizers, compared from the labels, for growers buying by the acre
Neptune's Harvest is the fish fertilizer most growers have heard of, and for good reason: it has been on the market since the 1980s and is sold in almost every garden center. TNT HEF 2-3-0 is made for the other end of the scale, row-crop and hay farms buying by the tote. Both are OMRI Listed for USDA organic production. Here is how they compare, using only what the labels, the OMRI listings and each company's own website say. We checked the facts about Neptune's Harvest on November 21, 2026; if you find something out of date, tell us and we will fix it.
| Feature | TNT HEF 2-3-0 | Neptune's Harvest Hydrolyzed Fish 2-4-1 |
|---|---|---|
| Who makes it, where | TNT Farming Solutions, Versailles, Indiana. Ships direct to farms in all 50 states. | Ocean Crest Seafoods (Neptune's Harvest), Gloucester, Massachusetts. Sold through garden retailers, online stores and direct. |
| How it is made | Whole saltwater salmon broken down by natural fermentation, then cold-pressed, so the oils, proteins and amino acids stay in. No heat processing. | Fish hydrolysate: fish broken down with enzymes in what the company describes as a cold process that preserves fish proteins and oils. |
| Guaranteed analysis | 2-3-0: 2% nitrogen (1.68% ammoniacal), 3% available phosphate. Midwest Laboratories measured 2.17% N and 3.48% P2O5. | 2-4-1: 2% nitrogen, 4% available phosphate, 1% soluble potash (label). |
| Stabilizer | Phosphoric acid, within the NOP rule that liquid fish must stay at pH 3.5 or above. | Phosphoric acid (listed on the label). |
| Organic status | OMRI Listed for USDA organic (NOP), product code tna-16447, certificate valid to March 1, 2027. | OMRI Listed for USDA organic (NOP), product code nhf-0644, listing expires September 1, 2027. |
| Label rates for field crops | In-furrow 2-4 qt/acre (diluted 1:10 or more); broadcast 2-4 qt/acre in 10+ gal water; foliar 0.5-4 qt/acre. Per-crop timing on our crop pages. | Label directions are written per gallon of water: 1 oz of concentrate per gallon for field and vegetable crops, applied at least four times a season. Farm-scale per-acre rates are available from the company. |
| Package sizes | By the gallon (8.5 lb) and in 275-gallon IBC totes (2,337.5 lb net). Totes are how most farms buy it. | Retail sizes from 18 oz to 5 gallons at garden retailers; drums and bulk through the company for farms. |
| What else is in it | Amino acids and volatile fatty acids from the salmon ferment (TNT HEF 2-0-0 tested at 71% total acids on a dry-matter basis), plus the carbon that feeds soil biology. | The company lists naturally occurring macro- and micronutrients, vitamins, enzymes, amino acids and growth hormones from the fish. |
| Published field trial data | A replicated 2025 corn strip trial (TNT program vs a conventional program on the same farm) is published on our Reports page, with the caveats that it is one farm and one season. | We did not find a replicated farm trial published on its website; it publishes customer testimonials and garden results. |
| Price | Quoted per tote with freight. Ask for a quote; the calculator shows cost per acre at your rate. | Retail pricing is published on its website and at retailers; farm pricing is by quote. |
| Try before you buy | Free sample for a strip trial, with a step-by-step trial guide and record sheet. | Small retail sizes make a garden-scale test easy. |
The Bottom Line
If you garden or run a few acres of vegetables, Neptune's Harvest is easy to find and easy to use, and it is a well-made product. If you farm row crops or hay and will put fish fertilizer on by the quart per acre across hundreds of acres, TNT HEF 2-3-0 is packaged, priced and labelled for that: tote quantities, per-acre rates for in-furrow, broadcast and foliar, and a published strip trial you can read before you commit.
Run them side by side. Ask us for a free sample, put TNT HEF 2-3-0 on three strips next to your normal program, and weigh the result. The trial guide tells you how to do it fairly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Neptune's Harvest OMRI Listed?
What is the difference between fish hydrolysate and fermented fish?
Can I use TNT HEF 2-3-0 the same way I used Neptune's Harvest?
Which one is cheaper per acre?
Does TNT ship to my state?
Where is the trial data?
Ready to Make the Switch?
Contact us to discuss how TNT organic biostimulants can improve your farm's performance.
Questions? Call us: 574-532-6201